This is where I share my thoughts of polish, pets, life in general. Click on any of the tabs below to find out more about the Pointless Cafe Blog.

FB Plugin

Tracking

Showing posts with label dupes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dupes. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Jessica Custom Nail Colour vs Chanel April, May and June

♥

Tonight I have a comparison for you between the Jessicas and the Chanels.

I've heard that some people are touting Jessica Desire, Flirtation and Love Story as possible dupes for Chanel April, May and June. So I thought we would just take a look and see for ourselves.



Jessica  Custom Nail Colour: Desire, Love Story and Flirtation
 -----------------------------------


First up - Chanel April vs Jessica Desire. Two coats of each - no top coat. Definitely not dupes. (Pure Ice Rumors is almost an exact dupe for Chanel April. To see that comparison post, click here.)



Chanel April vs Jessica Desire

Chanel April vs Jessica Desire

Chanel April vs Jessica Desire - indirect natural light

--------------------------------------------------------------------------


Next up, Chanel May vs Jessica Flirtation. I passed on Chanel May because pink isn't my favorite unless they're really opaque and have a perfect formula and I found Chanel May to be a little more finicky that I prefer for a color I don't love.

So...I've used the tester at my Chanel counter to swatch May on my pinky so I could compare for you.
Three coats of May and 2 coats of Flirtation. No top coat. Not dupes, but I definitely prefer Flirtation because it's more opaque, has a creamier formula and looks better with my skin-tone. (Sorry about the hurried messy application!)



Chanel May vs Jessica Flirtation

Chanel May vs Jessica Flirtation

Chanel May vs Jessica Flirtation

----------------------------------------------------------


And finally, Chanel June vs Jessica Love Story. I love June and in my opinion, it would be the hardest one of the three to dupe. But hold on! Ding ding ding! We have a winner! In my opinion (and I don't use the word dupe lightly) Jessica Love Story is true dupe for Chanel June.



Chanel June vs Jessica Love Story

Chanel June vs Jessica Love Story

Chanel June vs Jessica Love Story - indirect natural light

------------------------------------------------------------------------


What do you think? I'm personally stunned that Love Story is such a perfect match for June! I'm still good with my decision not to get May and I'm perfectly happy with Flirtation. Better formula and better shade for my skin-tone.

Just for the record I prefer Desire to April too because it's a little darker and less like that 80s dusty mauve/pink/red of April. Formulas were comparable on those two and on Love Story and June. Formula was better on Flirtation than May.

I think April and May are still both available at Chanel but June was an LE and is no longer available at Chanel.

But...Jessica Custom Nail Colour polishes ARE available at Ninja Polish. The 3 I've just shown you are from the Bliss is This Collection and are among the over 40 Jessica polishes stocked at Ninja Polish. They retail for $6 for full .5 oz bottles. You can also follow Ninja Polish on Facebook, Pinterest, Instagram, Google+ and Twitter to stay up-to-date on new lines, restocks, etc.








*PR Samples provided for my honest review

If you enjoyed this post, please take a second to "like" it! Thanks!

.

Friday, March 23, 2012

Illamasqua Stance - Comparison Photos

After applying Illamasqua Stance I started thinking I had something similar, so I went digging in my stash and came up with these to show you...












At first glance I thought I was going to have some dupes on my hands. But none are exactly dupes. As you can see, though, they are very similar. Illamasqua dried shiny while the other three dried like neons to a semi-matte finish. Illamasqua has slightly more purple - it's a tad darker.

As for formula though, I have to say that the Zoya and the Sinful Colors both applied more easily and with fewer coats than the Illamasqua did.

Illamasqua retails for  £13.50 (about $21.43 as I type this) at Illamasqua.com
Zoya retails for $8.00 at Zoya.com
Sinful Colors retails for $1.99 at Walgreens
Island Girl retails for under $5 (but I'm not sure where to purchase, other than in Hawaii, or the exact price as I got all mine via swaps)


What do you think?  Will it be Illamasqua for you or is the color difference insignificant enough that you will go for one of the others?


Don't forget to enter my One Year Blogaversary butter LONDON Giveaway!!!  
Ends March 30th!
 
 



If you enjoyed this post, please take a second to "like" it! Thanks!

Thursday, February 9, 2012

Chanel Tentation - Swatches, Review and Dupe Search

Chanel Tentation was the only one of the new Chanel Le Vernis colors I was comfortable ordering without swatching in person. The others - Distraction, Attraction and Frisson - I will just have to wait to see. I checked my local Chanel counter yesterday and they still have no idea when they'll be getting them in.

Tentation is described by Chanel as an "intense fuchsia" and that's a pretty good description. It's actually a cool-based red packed full of fuchsia/pink shimmer which does indeed give it an intense fuchsia appearance.

The photos are two coats with no top coat. Application was good, just as you would expect from a Chanel polish.

Chanel Tentation
Chanel Tentation

Chanel Tentation
Chanel Tentation

Chanel Tentation
Chanel Tentation

Chanel Tentation
Chanel Tentation
Chanel Tentation
Chanel Tentation


Someone asked how close Tentation was to Chanel Rouge Carat, so I did a quick comparison.

Chanel Tentation Comparison

Chanel Tentation Comparison



As you can see, they are totally different!

But as I wore Tentation throughout the day, I kept thinking I had something awfully similar.  So when I got home, I poked around my stash a bit and came up with a few to do comparison shots with.

Chanel Tentation Comparison
Chanel Tentation Comparison

Chanel Tentation Comparison
Chanel Tentation Comparison


As you can see, most of them aren't even close to being dupes.  There is one that is VERY similar though. OPI Peru-B-Ruby. It's the most similar in color AND finish.  As far as color, the Milani Speed Up Pink is the closest color match, but it has a sparkle rather than a shimmer and is a few more coats to get the color match.


Chanel Tentation Comparison
Chanel Tentation Comparison

They're not what I call dupes, but they're close. OPI Peru-B-Ruby is slightly darker and a smidge bit more on the red side of fuchsia than Tentation. They do have the same fuchsia/pink shimmer though. In this case, I'd choose Chanel Tentation. The formula is slightly better and Chanel is Cruelty-Free.

What do you think? Will you be getting this one? Or any of the new Chanel polishes?


If you enjoyed this post, please take a second to "like" it! Thanks!
.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Max Factor Fantasy Fire - Clarins 230 (Unicorn Pee) Dupe?

First off, this isn't a brand I usually buy anymore since it's not on my Cruelty-Free list (Max Factor is owned by Procter and Gamble) - not that there's much chance of me buying it because it's not available in the US. But when this came up, it didn't even occur to me, until after my friend in the UK (THANKS JO!!!) was already sending it to me, to check on Max Factor.  So there's my disclaimer.

But since I now have Fantasy Fire I decided to show it to you because there's been so much hype about whether it's a Clarins 230 (Unicorn Pee) dupe.

Is it?  I'll just show you photos first and then I'll let you know what I think.

The obligatory bottle shot... (which is TINY)

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire


I was wearing Zoya Kelly, so I used this as a base.

Zoya Kelly
Zoya Kelly


I took lots of photos trying to capture all the different "looks" - it flashes green, gold, copper, bronze and red. I used one coat with no top coat.

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

Fantasy Fire
Max Factor Fantasy Fire

So is it a dupe? Well, actually, it's the closest thing I've seen so far. I had Clarins 230 once upon a time and didn't really like it that well. (I know, I know - that's CRAZY TALK!) True. But I didn't feel like it applied evenly enough. This one, on the other hand, goes on even in one coat with no streaking and I didn't feel the need to go over and over it like I did with Clarins 230. (But don't get me wrong, I do love me a great Clarins creme.)

But this one was just so much easier. From what I remember, it flashes all the right ways to remind you of Unicorn Pee. So I'm calling it. YES. I think it's a great dupe. I will, of course, try layering it over other colors eventually. *rubs hands together with glee*

What do you think? Does it look like Clarins 230 to you?

I'm hearing that it's getting be be very hard to find in the UK now. Good luck scoring a bottle (or three) if you're after it!

Click here to enter my Winter Giveaway - ENDS FEBRUARY 8TH 


If you enjoyed this post, please take a second to "like" it! Thanks!
.

Friday, December 2, 2011

OPI My Private Jet Original Holo vs Non-Holo vs Spectraflair Comparison

When I started swatching these this evening, I discovered something I did NOT expect to find. I love happy accidents!!!  Especially when they are a DIRECT result of my laziness!

I was too lazy to go get another swatch wheel, so I used the one I'd been using from yesterday. Thankfully.  On it, I swatched OPI My Private Jet (original linear holo) and the newer version with some holo, but nothing even close to linear. And then another swatch of the non-holo so I could test out my Spectraflair holo top coat and see if that duped the original.

Here are those results.

First Original Holo (L) and new version (M & R)
Original Holo (L) New (M) with Spectraflair top coat (R)
Original Holo (L) New (M) with Spectraflair top coat (R)


As you can see, the Spectraflair top coat lightens/washes out the color a TINY bit so that they're not identical. Still pretty, still very close but not exact dupes. I'd say about 94%.

BUT WAIT!!!

What's that I see???  Remember when I first tested out my Spectraflair top coat on 5 different polishes on a swatch wheel? Well, one of THEM is actually almost identical to the original MPJ!!! That's where the lazy comes in. I was too lazy to grab a fresh swatch wheel or I might have never noticed it!

Zoya Petra with a Spectraflair top coat is a near-perfect dupe for the Original MPJ Holo! I'd say about 98%.

See?
Zoya Petra with Spectraflair top coat far left - click to make larger
Sorry I couldn't get a better photo. I'm still learning and trying to get the lighting stuff down.

Monday, September 12, 2011

Hard Candy Sky as a Chanel Riva Substitute?

Hard Candy Sky
          Hard Candy Sky


Okay, so here's the deal. If you LOVE Chanel Riva and will wear it more than once every few months, GET IT if you find it. If you like the look yet probably won't wear it often, you *could* get by with Hard Candy Sky.

I say *could* because when dry, the color isthisclose. AND it even has the shimmer! But as good as the formula and ease of application was on Hard Candy Beetle that I reviewed here recently, this formula is bad. Like PITA bad.

This is a pale powder blue/sky blue creme with a subtle blue shimmer.

Here's the closeup of the shimmer...

Hard Candy Sky
It really is a lovely color, but it was streaky on the first coat, streaky on the second coat and while the third coat achieved the right coverage, it then became thick and took on the texture of orange peel.

I did this mani last night and when I went to take photos in natural light after breakfast this morning, there was already tip wear and some chipping.

Check out this next photo.  Not acceptable.  Not acceptable at all.

Hard Candy Sky
Click the photo to enlarge and check out the wrinkling on the ring finger. (You can also see the shimmer in the bottle here.)

So while the color and shimmer may be so similar that it passes as a Chanel Riva dupe (and even taking into account the reported formula and application problems with Riva) in my opinion, if you like the look, you should just grab Riva next time you see it somewhere. Yes, even at eBay prices.

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

Chanel Graphite vs. OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous Part Deux

Continuing from last night's post with the comparison between Chanel Graphite and OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous, I've taken photos of the two in natural light.  As you can see, they are not identical.  That said, it's likely that you could wear both colors as your mani for a week and no one would notice that you have two different colors - except you, of course.

Chanel Graphite and OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous
Chanel Graphite and OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous

Chanel Graphite and OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous

You can see that the Chanel Graphite flashes gold (with a very subtle copper and green) in indirect sunlight. But you have to look really hard for the copper/green flashes and I wasn't able to capture them here.

Chanel Graphite and OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous

In full, direct sunlight, we are back to barely seeing ANY difference between the two at all.

To sum it up: without natural lighting almost perfect dupes; indirect natural light, not dupes; direct natural light, back to almost perfect dupes again.

Chanel Graphite vs. OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous

Are they dupes or aren't they?

Well, in spite of the photos you are going to see here, I can tell you that they're not.  Of course, it also depends on how close you want them to be.  Are they close?  Absolutely.

Below are some pics I snapped this evening - no natural light. And in this light, I can tell you they are dupes, right down to the application and number of coats (I used 2 coats on both.)

Chanel Graphite and OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous

Chanel Graphite and OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous


Chanel Graphite and OPI Lucerne-tainly Look Marvelous

I can actually tell now, but it's very subtle, plus the fact that I remember which fingers have which polish. Ha! But at arms-length, identical.

But just wait for the sunlight photos!  Tomorrow, I promise!