So I set about trying to get a close enough dupe to satisfy me. Will it satisfy everyone? Probably not. But I'm happy with it.
I started out with about 2/3rds of a bottle of Orchid Royal Engagement. Then I added 5 drops of each of the following:
*Sally Hansen Hard as Nails Black Heart
*Orchid Starry Night
*OPI DS Magic
*China Glaze Dorothy Who?
Then I added some Sterling Silver micro glitter (SuperNail brand from Sally Beauty Supply NOT the holo one) - about the size of 2 grains of rice.
This was the result, which I still wasn't completely happy with...
![]() |
Used Essie Matte About You on accent nail |
So...I layered over a coat of the top coat I had made last month using Seche Vite and the same Sterling Silver micro glitter and VOILA!
No, it's probably not an exact dupe, but I don't have the Essie one to compare and I'm actually totally happy with it! It's completely smooth - no "glitter feel" at all.
What do you think?
Those of you who have Essie Starry Starry Night, is it close at all?